Gringo Lost

Words about things and stuff

Testing the “civilian surge” in Helmand province

with 2 comments

Possibly the biggest test of population-centric counterinsurgency is underway in Helmand province after 4,000 troops entered the territory for Operation Khanjar (Dagger) some 3 weeks ago.  With the Taliban in retrograde defense – flushed from villages – US troops are moving forward, attempting to expand the central government’s reach and strengthen local government.

However, the civilian surge is considerably strained by resources and probably operating with less than 80 USAID and State Department personnel (estimates are based on this old article) .  These civilians are tasked to spread development assistance over an area of almost 60,000 square kilometers, making it extremely difficult to reach major outlays of land.

Another key to the COIN strategy in Helmand is reducing the area’s poppy cultivation.  To this end, US policy is now focused on crop replacement (over eradication) to create alternate economies aside from the poppy industry (Interestingly enough this is not the same approach that the coalition is taking).

However, this strategy has really only taken root in the northern and eastern parts of Afghanistan, areas which are much less reliant on the income from opium than is southern Afghanistan.  Indeed, Helmand’s opium production accounts for over half of Afghanistan’s and 40% of the world’s total production.  Not content with taking the time to introduce crop alternatives in Helmand, apparently the US has took its vengence on poppy plants by bombing the living sh*t out of them.

The military dropped a series of 1,000-pound bombs from planes on the mounds of poppy seeds and then followed with strikes from helicopters.

Another necessary goal for coalition troops is to enfranchise local voters and prepare them for the upcoming August 20 presidential and provincial elections.  But these efforts are hampered by squabbles amongst intervening forces and the local population.  As Pamela Constable writes, there are several elements that must be addressed before the Afghan government can replace Taliban authority in Helmand:

[US and British] officials said several factors, including a lack of qualified and educated workers in the remote province, a shortage of housing and office facilities for professionals from larger cities like Kandahar or Kabul, and a series of tensions and rivalries among various Afghan agencies, were impeding the kind of follow-up needed to convince residents that the Afghan government is credible, committed and a better alternative than the Taliban.

So, the outcome remains to be seen but the test is underway.  The questions: Can we transform Helmand in the way we want, or will the operation become too cumbersome?  If we do change it, will we need to stick around to ensure our changes remain?  And if we succeed, do we want to continue with this approach to other areas of Afghanistan?


2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Very insightful analysis of our current WOT in Afghanistan. As a veteran of the Vietnam war my thinking of wars of insurgencies has evolved over time. For the last three weeks I have been reading an obscure work, ‘Lost Years’ (my 1,632 days in Vietnamese Reeducation Camps) by Tran Tri Vu. What stunned me was the analysis by inmates, both ARVN and Nationalist (NLF) of the failures of the US understand the real enemy, our ignorance of the history of Vietnam, Communist Ideology, and how we snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. I’ve read it three times in three weeks. I especially focused on Page 300 to the end. To paraphrase, and apologies to the author. We essentially fell victim to North Vietnamese propaganda that the Communist’s were fighting a war of ‘National Liberation’. The former imprisioned Viet Minh found that a hard lesson to swallow. I just read this CIA monograph on the ‘Lessons of the Russian War in Afganistan’. If interested follow pdf link:
    Great work!


    July 24, 2009 at 7:06 pm

    • Thanks Blackhawk187,

      I’ll try to check out the “Lost Years” book when I get back to the States. If you have any other tips, I’d be glad to hear them.


      July 27, 2009 at 12:06 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: